Health Insurance: HMOs vs. PPOs
I wrote awhile back about choosing between an HMO and a PPO for our new health insurance plan. Thus, I was quite interested the other day when I ran across a Consumer Reports survey on this very topic…
First off, did you know that annual health insurance premiums for a family have increased by 59% since 2000? That’s six times the inflation rate! And employers are increasingly passing those higher costs on to their employees.
They also surveyed over 35,000 people about their HMOs and PPOs and found that only 64% of individuals were “completely satisfied” or “very satisfied” with their plan. Here are a few more interesting tidbits:
HMOs scored slightly higher in overall satisfaction than PPOs, which dovetails with other research that finds many consumers somewhat more willing to give up choice of provider to get lower costs.
We actually went with the PPO because we feel the exact opposite — we value choice over cost.
People in HMOs had more trouble obtaining care than members of PPOs.
No surprise there.
Nearly one-third of all PPO members reported billing problems, nearly three times the rate for people in HMOs.
This isn’t particularly surprising, either… HMOs have very slimmed down, simple billing systems.
There was no difference between HMOs and PPOs in levels of satisfaction among those with chronic conditions, except for people with back pain. Those patients were happier with PPOs.
This is sort of a curious finding… I’d expect PPOs to result in happier patients across the board, but it seems that amongst the chronically ill, there is only a slight advantage to PPOs.
[Source: Consumer Reports]
Published on October 13th, 2006 - 3 Comments
Filed under: Insurance
About the author: Nickel is the founder and editor-in-chief of this site. He's a thirty-something family man who has been writing about personal finance since 2005, and guess what? He's on Twitter!
Related articles...
» From the Archives (October 7th – October 13th)» How to Save Money on Health Insurance
» High-Deductible Health Insurance and Health Savings Account (HSA) Update
» Save on Healthcare: Cheap Immunizations at the Health Department
» Save Big on Well-Child Care
» Insurance Needs for a Couple with No Kids
» One Year Ago This Week (July 23rd – July 29th)
» Erroneous Medical Bill Update
Was this article useful? Please sign up to receive our content via e-mail:
3 Responses to “Health Insurance: HMOs vs. PPOs”
Leave a Reply
Top Cards by Category
Earn $200 Bonus Cash Back after you make $500 in purchases in your first 3 months. 5% Cash Back on up to $1,500 spent in bonus categories each quarter.
Earn 25,000 Membership Rewards(R) bonus points when you spend $1,000 in your first three months of Card membership.
Receive 10,000 Membership Rewards bonus points when you spend $1,000 in 3 months of Card membership.
Earn up to 5% cash back* in categories that change and enjoy a 0% introductory rate for 15 months on Balance Transfers and 15 months on Purchases.
Enjoy no balance transfer fee for a limited time. 0% introductory rate on Balance Transfers and Purchases. Earn up to 5% Cashback Bonus in categories that change like gas, restaurants, department stores and more. Limitations apply*
Enjoy no balance transfer fee for a limited time. 0% introductory rate on Balance Transfers and Purchases. Earn up to 5% Cashback Bonus in categories that change like gas, restaurants, department stores and more. Limitations apply*
Enjoy amenities for you and your business, like: complimentary airport club access, including American Airlines Admirals Club(R) lounges.
5% Cashback Bonus in categories that change like gas, restaurants, department stores and more. Limitations apply*. Up to 1% unlimited Cashback Bonus on everything else. No annual fee
Earn 3X points on airfare, 2X points on gas and groceries, and 1X points on everything else.
Reports to 3 major credit bureaus monthly and acceptance at millions of locations worldwide, including website purchases and reservations.
- How to Become a Millionaire
- How to Get Out of Debt
- The Best Dollars I've Ever Spent
- How Our Estate Plan is Structured
- How We Paid Our Mortgage In Less than 10 Years
- Money Making Ideas
- How to Manage Your Asset Allocation with Multiple Accounts
- Consumption Smoothing - Save While the Saving's Good
- How to Save on Groceries
- How Much Life Insurance Do You Need?
- Eleven Great Books About Money
- Dave Ramsey is Bad at Math
- Dish Network Customer Service SUCKS
- $8,000 Homebuyer Tax Credit
- Pay Off Mortgage Early or Invest?
- How to Claim the First-Time Homebuyer Tax Credit
- Reduced Credit Limits? Share Your Experience
- $15,000 Homebuyer Tax Credit
- Ethanol Blended Gas = Lower Mileage?
- Termite Control: Sentricon vs. Termidor
- How Much Should You Pay a Babysitter?
- Federal Income Tax Rates Went Down but Your Federal Tax Withholding Increased. Here's Why...
- Would the "Fair Tax" Gut the Economy?
How to save money on insurance
- Double-Check Your Ally CDs
- Stocks are Not Bonds, CDs, or Savings Accounts
- The Best Values in Colleges - 2012 Edition
- Five Myths About Renter's Insurance
- Own Your Investments, Rent Your Fun
- Citibank to Issue Credit Cards in China
- Heartstrings and Pursestrings
- Saving Money at the Grocery Store: Store Brand Pricing on the Rise
- Missing Tax Paperwork?
- Is Your Investment Allocation Right?

Tip It!
October 13th, 2006 at 8:55 am
I’ve been pretty happy with the coverage I’ve received from my HMO family plan, but the cost increases have been pretty brutal.
My health insurance premium has increased by 51% since 2001, and it would have gone up quite a bit higher if I didn’t downgrade my plan to one with higher co-pays and deductibles.
October 13th, 2006 at 9:06 am
I actually have a POS plan (no seriously that is its name) and the means except for hospitals I can chose any service provider. I have you all beat, my premium went up 38.3% this year.
June 12th, 2008 at 6:07 am
I too have a POS,(point of service). Priour to that, I had an HMO. I like being having the flexibility to goto different doctors.