Comments (scroll down to add your own):

1. When I had my similar incident, after I told the body shop it was an insurance claim, they would only accept the check from the insurance company as payment. Otherwise, it would’ve gone on a reward credit card. The body shop actually had to cut me a check of their own since part of the insurance company’s check was for rental car reimbursement.

   This struck me as rather odd, and maybe not legal or correct, but I didn’t complain.

   Comment by Nick — Mar 13th 2007 @ 10:14 am

2. In our fender bender (a one-car weather-related accident), the insurance company, cut the award to the bone, according to the garage. They had to take it, since they had agreed to be a reference garage (just like the doctor has to accept whatever Blue Cross pays if he want any Blue Cross patients, no matter what his “real” bill is.) If we had been paying out of pocket, they would not have done the work for what the insurance paid.

   Which makes it difficult to do the reward card maneuver, to say the least.

   Longer story short, after meeting the high deductible on this (luckily) old car, we were better off just trading it in for salvage value on a new car–and avoiding a claim and the black mark that puts on your insurance. We still drive that new car, 13 years later!

   Comment by geo — Mar 13th 2007 @ 1:02 pm

3. But think about trade in value for the van if you leave the dent there (and subsequently get rust)
   Car repairs are such a pain!

   Comment by Karen — Mar 13th 2007 @ 1:03 pm

4. No, the really frugal thing to do would deposit the money into a high yield account until you decide to get the car fixed.

   Comment by Pete — Mar 14th 2007 @ 7:58 am

5. I seem to be experiencing similar karma this week.

   This week my 16 year old daugher was in two minor fender-benders, and I was in one.

   Monday in the school parking lot. She was backing out and the other car was coming down the driveway the “wrong way” against the arrow, so both were at least partly at fault. Jut a couple of scratches on the ‘99 Chevy, so on big deal. Probably won’t fix.

   On my way home that same after noon I let my car roll up a bump the car in front of me at a pull out. We bouth got out and looked, but there was no damage so we both went on.

   Then Friday she was going to wash her car and was stopped at a 4-way stop. She got rear ended and it did crumple the bumper in some, so we will probably get something fixed on that one.

   Comment by theWizard — Mar 18th 2007 @ 1:36 pm

6. Dont you just love those reward credit cards. I once had it where a guy backed into me and then said his company would be in touch. I never heard back for days so i phoned them left a message that I wasnt going to mess about and was going through my insurance, then then called and said meet them in the car park to discuss this.. Im like.. not likely..

   I went through my insurance and got my car sorted..

   Who knows what could have happened to me had i gone there.

   Comment by CreditNine.com — Mar 20th 2007 @ 8:34 pm

Leave a comment