Comments (scroll down to add your own):

1. I only read the electronic versions, but I enjoy both Money and Kiplingers. I also love The Economist and the Wall Street Journal, even if it’s not technically a magazine. I have found interesting articles in Smart Money from time to time, but they focus too much on investment hyperactivity for my tastes.

   Comment by Kyle — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 10:19 am

2. I prefer Money Magazine as I feel as though I can relate to the articles being presented.

   Comment by SingleGuyMoney — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 10:48 am

3. Of the ones you mentioned I take Money, Smart Money, and Kiplinger’s. I least like Smart Money – it really isn’t geared for me. It’s geared for people who are wealthier (middle class millionaires). They talk about antiques, expensive wine and chocolate, buying art, Cadillacs and renting villas in the Carribean. It’s a bit elitist for my liking (and I have 2 grad degrees and married an MD – I thought I’d be the elitist). But I still take the magazine and read it – some interesting information available.

   My favorite is Kiplinger’s. I like both it and Money. But Kiplinger’s won me over when it ran a Green Issue a few months back focusing on ways to make money by “going green and investing green.” At first I read it as any other magazine (I’m not exactly a “greenie.”) But Kiplinger’s took a lot of backlash for that issue from conservatives and they defended their point by saying they don’t take a political stance, but rather look at ways to save their reader’s money, and that was what the issue focused on. I liked their opinion and gumption to stand up to the bullies. My guess is the majority of folks at Kiplinger’s are conservative, but they realize their mission is to save money for their readers and that’s what they were doing. I really respect their viewpoint now regardless of their or my political leanings. We are focused on the same goal – saving and making me money!

   Comment by KC — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 11:22 am

4. I have a paper subscription to Kiplinger’s, which is really easy on the eys. Everything else I read comes from my massive RSS feed reader, but you pretty much covered all the periodic publications.

   Comment by Lily — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 11:40 am

5. I subscribe to Business Week. Its not really per-se for investment I think but more if you are interested in knowing whats happening in the business world. I like the background knowledge I get from it in order to round up my knowledge needed to make good investments. I am also interested in subscribing to another financial magazine so I will interested in hearing what other’s find useful.

   Comment by Amol — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 11:40 am

6. Currently I only subscribe to Money, but I might have to try Kiplinger’s after all these good comments.

   Comment by YoungMoneyHabits — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 11:42 am

7. I have been a subscriber to Money magazine for probably 6+ years. I have found this to be my favorite, and the one I am most likely to read all the articles in. I found that I didn’t care as much for Kiplingers and Forbes — both seemed to spend to much time promoting activities I wasn’t interested in: mainly, actively trading stocks and/or funds, hyping the latest high performing funds, and promoting active management. As an indexer, following a more “stay the course” technique, these 2 magazines just weren’t interesting enough to me.

   Comment by Thad — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 11:54 am

8. You may be able to get free subscriptions to some of the personal finance trade magazines like Financial Planning, Investment Advisor, Wealth Manager, Financial Advisor, Journal of Indexes, employee benefit advisor, etc, as a personal finance blogger (may be worth trying). If not, you may be able to get discarded issues from local financial professionals when they’re done with them.

   Money is really the only one you mentioned that I regularly find to have interesting content. Business Week and Kiplinger’s are hit or miss and Smart Money, Forbes, and Fortune are mostly miss, IMO. I actually currently get them all thanks to expiring Delta frequent flyer miles. I don’t have much experience with CR Money Advisor but I like CR.

   Comment by Dylan — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 11:59 am

9. I’ve really been liking Kiplinger’s recently, I have found a lot of articles that really appealed to me on everything from credit to careers to investing.

   @KC, I have to chuckle when you point out that SmartMoney is elitist. My first job was writing for SmartMoney, and I learned how to sound as snobby as possible in as few words as possible. That said, I’ve often thought SmartMoney might be hurting themselves with that tone.

   They write for the readers they think they have, but I’ll bet more of their readers are ambitious but still struggling than already-made millionaires.

   Comment by David — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 12:05 pm

10. Don’t do it — it’s not worth the time to read anything besides Money. I’ve let all my subscriptions, except for Money, expire.

    But if you insist, the only other one I’d recommend is Kiplinger’s.

    Now if you want real fun and a GREAT magazine, go for The Family Handyman magazine.

    Comment by FMF — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 12:14 pm

11. I haven’t liked any of the financial magazines I’ve seen except for Consumer Reports (not the Money Adviser but just the regular magazine). They tend to focus on day-trading issues and rich-people issues. I don’t care what the hot stocks are and I don’t care where to get the best luxury accommodations in exotic vacation resorts.

    Even Consumer Reports has major problems for me: they sometimes are too ignorant to even know what to test (electronics, especially) and then tend to test only big-ticket items. Also, they pretend to be catering to the entire US, but it’s clear they are based in the northeast–they often talk about regional retailers that aren’t available to me, gardening practices that would be very loopy for people in hot climates to follow, etc.

    I prefer blogs. Seeing what regular people are dealing with on a daily basis is much more valuable to me. And that’s true even though most of you guys are much younger than me, have much higher salaries than I do, and are still getting out of consumer and/or student loan debt. For example, I learned about online savings accounts, money-saving recipes, and strategies for making your spending fit better with your values from blogs.

    I’d also rather re-read The Tightwad Gazette and Your Money or Your Life than to read those magazines. They get me back in the proper mindset when the commercializing brainwashing has gotten to me again! Those money magazines feel like part of the brainwashing.

    Comment by Debbie M — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 12:52 pm

12. I don’t subscribe to any magazines, but I do read their counterparts online. Most of the time I find myself reading Business Week, The Economist and Kiplingers.

    Comment by JSB — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 1:10 pm

13. If you really want to take your financial knowledge to the next level, a daily subscription to the Wall Street Journal is the best way to achieve it. You will find that it is not only for brokers and New York bankers. It has a wealth of personal financial articles (even a section devoted to it each week). By reading a few of the leading articles each day, you begin to understand the bigger picture of finance and economics, translating to a better understanding of money. An instructor at my local college required it of his finance students, and it has made all the difference to me.

    Comment by Brad Franzwa — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 1:28 pm

14. I’m with Debbie here. I don’t read magazines either. Whether in electronic or paper form.

    Blogs are great and I can almost always learn something neat.

    Comment by Lau — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 1:35 pm

15. Oh the irony of a financial blog with the motto “because money matters” asking for subscription magazine recommendations! Don’t waste your money on dinosaur media. They’re cutting staff and shrinking their page counts. Go online where it’s free, where it’s AT, baby! On the Internets! As invented by Al Gore.

    Comment by Kris — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 1:45 pm

16. I subscribe to both BusinessWeek and Money. I really enjoy reading both, and the information is relevant and timely. I really like the BusinessWeek is weekly (duh) and Money is monthly. It’s the perfect amount of reading for me. I used to get the WSJ, but the amount of information every day was like trying to drink from a firehose.

    Comment by Mike — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 2:11 pm

17. I found copies of Better Investing in my local library. It’s a bit more technical than I’m ready for, but they do seem go to a lot of effort to do cover some basics as well as step through an analysis of a real company’s information and talk about why it is or isn’t a good investment.

    For instance, I learned a little bit on a blog (FMF?) about “short selling” which I’ve always wondered about. Part of the discussion was that you borrowed shares from the broker. What I DIDN’T realize from that discussion (and others) was that you needed to open a margin account and that you would likely be charged interest while you held your stocks. I learned that in a similar discussion in Better Investing. (at least, if I’m remembering it correctly). Nothing earth shattering to those who are experienced I’m sure, but I’m a newbie.

    I haven’t rigorously researched it to see if it has some sort of bias.

    Comment by BigBroodGander — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 3:14 pm

18. BigBroodGander: You may have learned about shorting stock from me in this article/

    Comment by nickel — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 3:19 pm

19. Yep, that’s it.

    I Don’t mean to demean your effort there, it’s certainly a fine intro but since I’m such a newbie, I didn’t understand that the margin account would be involved and that it was an additional downside.

    I had read about it in other places as well, and none of them mentioned that the extra cost was going on…or they may have called it a “margin account” which is meaningless to me (though I’m now beginning to understand more…)

    All told, I really understood that I shouldn’t be messing with “shorting” until I understand a LOT more about investing in general.

    Comment by BigBroodGander — Apr 2nd 2008 @ 4:10 pm

20. Does the Economist count? It is really useful for it’s economic analysis and general business trends. I also read business week but I find it so shallow that I typically just take about an hour to flip through it every week.

    Comment by Shadox — Apr 3rd 2008 @ 3:16 am

21. As a total investing/financial novice, I still find that Kiplingers and Money are the easiest to comprehend. My husband and I have subscribed to the Consumer Reports Money Advisor, but I’ve been disappointed with it….it is more like a newsletter than a true periodical, the topics are not covered thoroughly, more like headlines with one or two paragraphs following, much like you would see in a newspaper. It also only comes once a month. We don’t plan to re-subscribe to this one.

    Comment by Beth — Apr 3rd 2008 @ 11:37 am

22. I used to read Kiplingers and Money, but now that most of the articles are online I canceled my paper subscriptions.

    Comment by My Dollar Plan — Apr 3rd 2008 @ 9:25 pm

Leave a comment