Comments (scroll down to add your own):

1. Since the chase freedom doesn’t have tiers, it’ll earn you more if you spend under $13,000 a year. Amex blue wins over $13k.

   However, don’t forget that with the chase freedom card, if you wait until you hit $200 in cash back before redeeming it, they’ll give you $250 ($50 bonus). That makes it the equivalent of 3.75% in the top 3 categories and 1.25% for everything else, still without any tiers. Accounting for this you’d have to be spending A LOT (well over $13k, too lazy to do the exact math) on your credit card for the amex blue to pay out more than the chase freedom card.

   Comment by FlatGreg — Aug 26th 2008 @ 1:49 pm

2. FlatGreg: Yes, if you don’t spend much, that low tier eats into your earnings. Even accounting for that, however, we’re still right around 1.9%. YMMV, of course. And yes, I’m a big fan of the extra $50 for every $200 in rewards that you build up on the Freedom card. What I really need to do is an analysis of our combined earnings between the two cards.

   Comment by nickel — Aug 26th 2008 @ 2:04 pm

3. I also have both these cards, but primarily use the Chase Visa for the reason you stated: AmEx is not reliably accepted by everyone. So I prefer to just consolidate everything on one card. One great bonus with the Chase card is that if you wait to redeem rewards until you have $200, they give you $250.

   Comment by See My Money — Aug 26th 2008 @ 2:43 pm

4. Does the Amex Blue Cash have a pre-set spending limit or do they act like the other Amex cards where you have no spending limit but pay in full?

   The reason I ask is more for credit scoring purposes, where I believe if it has no spending limit…it uses the most you spent in one month as the ‘limit’. So if I spent $2000 in one month that’s my new “Credit Limit” when companies pull up my credit report. I worry that it would negatively affect my Debt Ratio if applying for a new loan if I have $1500 balance at the time I apply in the future (planning on buying a new car within the next 1-3 years).

   Comment by Mark — Aug 26th 2008 @ 3:03 pm

5. Mark: It has a limit, so no worries there.

   Comment by nickel — Aug 26th 2008 @ 3:08 pm

6. If you bank at Chase you get 3% back on your top 5 categories. Also you get a $50 check or statement credit with your first purchase.

   Comment by Thrifty Femme — Aug 26th 2008 @ 3:43 pm

7. My wife and I use primarily the Blue Cash, and I have the Chase Freedom card as a non-AMEX backup. I’ve been wondering if there were better options out there, so it’s nice to see someone else using the same setup.

   Comment by Qwunk — Aug 26th 2008 @ 3:45 pm

8. I am finding more and more places are taking AMEX (at least in Oregon) in the past 2 years. My hunch is that the increase is due to the large influence of Costco, which got its start here in the Pacific NW. They are really pushing the AMEX card, and so more and more people have that card to use. That, and retailers that may compete with Costco now have to accept the card or lose business.

   That, or AMEX has lowered their merchant fee…possibly a combination of both.

   Comment by Steve — Aug 26th 2008 @ 3:48 pm

9. That’s the problem that I have – American Express isn’t taken at enough places for me to get that far over the $6,500 mark. Plus I’m lucky enough to be grandfathered in another card that gives me 5% off the everyday purchases from the first dollar spent.

   Still I think I’d go with the Chase Freedom card in general. There’s a good Chase business rewards card that also gives you a 3% at restaurants, office supply, and home improvement stores. These come in handy.

   Comment by Lazy Man and Money — Aug 26th 2008 @ 10:22 pm

10. I’ve spoken to my mother on reward cards as well…and she does the CitiBank Thank You Rewards. They had an offer where she got 5:1 for Gas/Groceries/etc for the first year. When the year is up, she signs up for another card, and gets 5:1 for another year, and the points go to the same “Thank You” account.

    What are your thoughts on this?

    Comment by Mark — Aug 26th 2008 @ 10:27 pm

11. Not trying to jack your blog or the recommended card, but for those who aren’t high spenders when it comes to using their credit cards you may want to consider either the following cards:
    PenFed Cash Back Platinum card (5% cash back for gas purchases, 2% cash back for grocery purchases, 1.25% cash back on everything else; need to be a member, but that only costs $5 initially to join the credit union)
    Chase Freedom (as mentioned by previous posters)
    Orchard Bank Card (2% cash back on all purchases)
    Associated Bank Cash Back Card (5% cash back on gas and grocey, 1% on everything else, but reward is limited to total of $300)

    Comment by Cheapo — Aug 26th 2008 @ 11:20 pm

12. Cheapo: Thanks for the suggestions. When I joined PenFed, I had to join the NMFA for $20. Their card is a solid alternative, but I’d hate to give up that extra 3% on groceries. I agree on Chase Freedom, and highlighted it in my article as my backup card of choice (for place that don’t take Amex). As for the Orchard Bank card, I don’t see the 2% cash back listed on any of their offers (though I may have missed it). Moreover, most of their cards carry an annual fee. Not sure if the one that you’re thinking of falls into this category, but it’s something to be on the lookout for. And finally, that $300 cap on the Associated Bank card is a big negative in my book.

    Comment by nickel — Aug 26th 2008 @ 11:35 pm

13. We do the exact same thing. we use Amex Blue Cash for most our purchases. Those that don’t take Amex, we put it on Chase Rewards.

    Comment by Double Journey — Aug 27th 2008 @ 1:36 am

14. We LOVE our Amex Blue Cash! November will mark our 2nd anniversary with it. Last year we got $300 back and this year it’ll be around $400! Hey, I’ll take it, especially since it’s on money we would have spent whether we were using the Amex or not. I used to use the Amex Blue (with just rewards points) and didn’t see as much value as the only items worth getting were gift cards. The Cash is so much better.

    We put everything (minus the monthly bills) on the Amex. It’s how we keep track of our spending and budgeting (and of course we pay it all off each month). DH’s job requires him to drive all over a metro area daily and that right there puts $400+ on it each month. Add in groceries, dining out, and all our other expenses, and we’re looking at $1500-2000/month for us. We have a Chase card with a very low fixed APR that we use as a back-up. There are very few places we go that won’t take the Amex and of all our spending, there’s usually less than $100 on that card each month.

    And for the previous poster, the Amex Blue/Blue Cash cards are just like regular credit cards. You can carry a balance, with a typical APR, and there are no annual fees.

    Comment by Lissa — Aug 27th 2008 @ 10:48 am

15. Interesting…I am not sure if there is something like that here in Australia. I need to do some research and find out. We obviously have AMEX cards but did not come across anything with cash rewards like this. I need to find out.

    Comment by Sandy Naidu — Aug 28th 2008 @ 12:27 am

16. While it’s not a “cash back” card per se, I would have to say that my MBNA/Bank of America 529 card that returns a flat 2% to a 529 Fidelity college savings plan is the best card I am aware of if you or anyone in your family plans to ever attend college. No annual fee. I put everything on this card including business travel and literally have saved five figures for college over a six year period. I really cannot recommend it highly enough if you have kids or plan to go back to school at any point.

    Comment by Matt Straz — Aug 28th 2008 @ 5:33 pm

17. Household Bank has a 2% on everything card, $400 annual limit (which I will never get anywhere near). HSBC is the provider, I believe its pretty similar to the Orchard card which is also HSBC. There can be a fee if you have poor credit, there’s a two stage application procedure where they screen you and tell you what terms they will offer.

    They also offer 6 months of 0% on purchases, which is a nice little bonus.

    I use Chase Freedom for groceries and the Household card for everything else.

    Comment by akb — Aug 29th 2008 @ 3:33 pm

18. Disclaimer: I know you don’t like points cards but follow me for a second. I use the points for gift cards for gifts and my wife is addicted to Starbucks, but any way I use the Citi Platinum Amex, it gives 5% to everyday and then 3% to everything else, annual fee waived after the first year off course. Plus 15,000 points after $300 dollars in purchases. Which is equivalent to $150 in gift cards.

    Comment by Josh — Sep 3rd 2008 @ 4:24 pm

19. I have both Chase Freedom and Amex Blue Cash. I would use the Freedom however I never can get the maximum 3% back (max $12 a month, Amex no max). According my own spending I come out a little better with the Blue Cash not even spending $10k a year. Less hassle for me than the Freedom card though I love it as my second card.

    Comment by Bob — Jan 16th 2009 @ 7:14 am

20. Chase is discontinuing rewarding $200 rewards with $250 cash starting on July 1, 2009. And for business you need $900 to get $1000.
    So much for that one..

    Comment by Mike — Jun 18th 2009 @ 12:13 pm

21. BEWARE…AE Blue now pays only 1.25% after $6,500 spent (5% for gas & groceries).

    Comment by Dan — Jul 30th 2009 @ 10:38 pm

Leave a comment