A woman came in to my office the other day and asked this exact question. Actually, she didn’t ask the question – I did.
She had $50,000 in credit card debt (clicking away at 12%). What surprised me was that she had the $50,000 to pay off the credit card debt, but she didn’t plan on paying off the card. She wanted to invest the money instead. She estimated that she could earn much more than the 12% she was paying on the credit card so she concluded that paying it off was a silly thing to do.
It turns out that this woman was in hock all over town even though she had substantial assets. Never mind that her credit score was in the dumpster, she wanted to invest. I had to convince her to reconsider.
To you and me, the answer in this person’s case might be a no-brainer. But other situations aren’t so clear cut.
To address this issue, you have to understand all the components of the question.
First, there is the financial question which is rather simple. Ask yourself which number is greater; the return on your investment or the interest you are paying. If you are paying more interest than you could earn, you are far better off by paying down the debt.
For example, assume you owe $10,000 on a credit card. Say you actually have $10,000 in the bank which you could use to get out of debt completely. The credit card interest rate is 10% and the bank is paying you 1%. At first, this seems like a slam dunk. Pay off the credit card. Right? Not so fast.
Assume you also have an opportunity to invest $10,000 in your brother’s “can’t lose” vending machine business. He tells you that investments are earning 30%. Now, the choice becomes more complicated.
If you pay off the credit card, you are making a guaranteed 10% because that’s money that you’ll keep in your pocket rather than send off to Visa or Mastercard.
If you invest in the vending machine business, you are guaranteed nothing. You might earn 30% – or more. But you could also lose everything. It’s happened once or twice in the past when people invest in small business.
So which is greater? A guaranteed 10% or a possible 30%? The only way to approach this is to estimate the likelihood of earning that 30%. If the chances are high, you might go for it. If not, you might pass.
But there are other scenarios. What if the cost of that credit card debt was only 5%, and your alternative to paying that off is to invest in some mutual funds? What if your time frame was 5 years for those mutual funds. Assume you estimate that the average return of the funds over that period of time will be at least 8%? Which do you choose?
While you still have to do the above calculation of estimating the likelihood of achieving those results, you have the added element of time to consider. What is the expected return of the alternatives over the given time horizon?
So from a financial stand point, you have to consider alternatives, the cost of the debt and the likelihood of potential alternatives coming about and the downside risks over a given time frame. It’s a lot to consider.
Beyond these financial considerations, there are also the emotional points. How would you feel if you paid off the debt? How would you feel if you don’t invest? How would you feel if the investment doesn’t work out?
I have found that these emotional questions are just as important as the financial questions. What good is it to make an otherwise smart financial decision if at the end of the day you are left feeling miserable?
In most cases, you can simply ask yourself a few questions and come up with a really solid decision to address both the financial and the emotional issues:
1. What happens if you pay off the debt and the other investment does well?
Your answer will be unique depending on the situation. If the investment turns out great, how might it change your life? Are you giving up your chance of a lifetime? Or are the upsides of the investment actually very limited? What are you giving up in order to pay off the debt? Does it make sense to make that decision?
2. What happens if you pay off the debt and the other investment does poorly?
If this happens, you’ll probably feel like a genius. No problem here.
3. What happens if you don’t pay off the debt, make the investment and it turns out well?
What is a reasonable expectation for a good outcome and what does that look like? Can your money double? Triple? Or is the upside, even in the best case, so limited that it just isn’t worth it? What is a reasonable expectation?
4. What happens if you hold the debt, make the investment and it turns out badly?
Can you afford to lose the money and be stuck with the debt? A man I know borrowed money to invest in the stock market. Not only that, but he invested very aggressively and lost 30% in 3 months. At the end of the day, he was $150,000 underwater and needed to pay 10% to his lender. This bad decision forced him to sell his business and declare bankruptcy. Clearly, he never thought about the downside before choosing the investment over staying out of debt. He was an optimist who never considered the risk.
I have found that by asking myself these 4 questions, I make better financial decisions between two competing alternatives. How do you decide between paying down debt or investing?