The Best Cash Back Reward Credit Cards for Buying Gas

With gas prices skyrocketing, I thought it would be worth putting together a roundup of the best credit cards when it comes to cash back rewards on gas purchases. The good news is that there are still some pretty sweet deals out there.

What follows is an overview of one of the best options for a “mainstream” gas reward credit card. While there are a number of brand-specific offers available, I much prefer to be able to choose amongst gas stations based on price as opposed to being tied down to a single brand. Here goes…

TrueEarnings® Card from Costco and American Express

This is a TrueEarnings Consumer Card, the beauty of this card is that it offers you 3% cash back on gasoline at U.S. gas stations for purchases up to $4, 000 per year (1% thereafter) including the already cheap gasoline at Costco. In addition you can earn 2% cash back on purchases at U.S. restaurants, 2% cash back on eligible travel purchases, including at Costco and 1% on other purchases, including Costco. Cash back is earned only on eligible purchases and you will receive your cash back in the form of an annual reward coupon. There are spend caps and other restrictions that apply. Terms and restrictions apply. If you’re already a Costco member, the TrueEarnings card is definitely worth checking out. This card has no annual fee as long as your Costco membership is paid up. Unfortunately, our nearest Costco is close to an hour away, so this one doesn’t work for us.

There is also a business version of this card TrueEarnings® Business Card from Costco and American Express OPEN as well.

NOTE: Offers change frequently; please be sure to check the card issuers website to ensure that all details and information are correct.

30 Responses to “The Best Cash Back Reward Credit Cards for Buying Gas”

  1. Scott: There are no cards that offer 3% across the board. However, you can use something like the Chase Freedom card which pays 3% on your top three spending categories (see a list here). I actually use a hybrid approach, where I use the Amex Blue Cash wherever possible and Chase Freedom wherever Amex isn’t accepted.

    Also, Chase is offering a $50 signup bonus and they add $50 to your rewards if you accrue $200 before requesting a check. This increases your effective rewards by 25%.

    Hope this helps!

  2. Anonymous

    I just got the AMEX Blue cash because of the rewards but am finding many retailers won’t accept it (Cousins Subs, Halmark, Advance Auto to list a few). Also my 2 local grocery stores don’t accept it either (small town) so I am not able to maximize my earnings. Is there a Visa or MC out there that just pays a straight 3% without all kinds of formulas or categories to worry about?

  3. Nickel

    ns: That’s a 60 day promo, at which time you fall back to 3%. Why not get an unbranded 5% card? That way you can get 5% everywhere, included Gulf.

  4. Anonymous

    For my gas purchases I use the Barclays Gulf Platinum MasterCard. It gives me 3% on Gulf purchases, and I have 2 Gulf locations near my home and they are the closest gas stations to my home so it works out that way.

    I know BP and Shell have better rates at 5%, but I have been using this card for years and the rewards is in the form of Gulf Gas gift cards, so when I go to the station next I just pay with Gulf gift cards and essentially get free gas!

    Anyone else have this card? Do you like it of hate it?

    P.S. Ooops, Looks like they now offer 6% on Gulf Gas!!!! That is the highest I know of if you can dedicate yourself to one brand, though knowing Juniper/Barclays they will make me reapply for a new account! not just change my rewards T&C. Ughghg

  5. Nickel

    Jacky: I post all kinds of money saving tips here – click around. If you have self-discipline, swiping a credit card is a fantastic way to save 5% on gas. And the higher the price of gas goes, the more valuable this discount will be.

  6. Anonymous

    It is too bad that you cannot find a better response than suggesting people get credit cards to save money. A credit card is the last thing strapped people need to save money. Listen to Dave Ramsey.

  7. Anonymous

    The Costco Amex rebate is paid out with your Feburary statement yearly. The Costco 2% rebate for your executive membership is paid out on your costco anniversary date. Sometimes people get the two mixed up if they have both.
    You don’t have to spend it at Costco if you don’t want to. If you go to membership and ask them to cash either payout they will.
    It is usually not a problem with us because we alway spend the amount we get back at Costco anyhow.

  8. Anonymous

    Actually, if you are a Costco business member (which you do have to have a business name and license), you get 5% back on gas anywhere, 3% for eating out, 2% on travel, and 1% on everything else. Plus, you get a free membership to Hertz #1 Gold. This is really cool, as when I go on a business trip I get an instant savings on the rental for the Gold card, then an instant 5% savings on the rental on top of that (charged back to the card as credit), and then 2% for the travel rebate. Mariott hotels also give the same deal. By far the best cash back card for a business owner, and last year I got back 500 bucks. This year, with my new job requiring more travel, I will probably get about 1000 cash back, and most of that money was reimbursed by the company.

    I only keep a world points Visa card for places that don’t take Amex, which is getting to be fewer and fewer establishments.

  9. Anonymous

    I am not sure if they still offer it, but I have a Shell Gad Card (Also a credit card) that gives me a 5% rebate on all fuel purchases and 1% on everything else. My wife and I share a card and use in ONLY FOR GAS. So, at $4.00 a gallon, with the 5% rebate, we are actually paying $3.80 a gallon for gas. Not too bad. The only catch is you only get the rebate at Shell gas stations. This is not a problem since there are several by my home and they are actually the cheapest around (currently 3.89$). Thoughts?

  10. Nickel

    You’re lucky they grandfathered you in with the old deal. They usually just slash rewards across the board regardless of how long you’ve had the card.

  11. Anonymous

    Nope for life 5% cash back on gas, drug store, groceries and 1% on everything else. Limit is $300/year in earnings though.

    We got the card a long time ago and it still gives us massive rewards. They cancelled it I think because people were using it too much or something.

    It’s now citibank simplicity rewards, not nearly as lucrative.

  12. Anonymous

    penfed credit union has a card that gives you 5% back on all gas purchases paid at the pump with no max and no threshold to reach first. If you can’t find a way you qualify to join the credit union, you can pay a $20 membership fee to the National Military Family Association which qualifies you for membership.

    I was going to do this until I found a local credit union that I could join that has the same kind of card.

    Might be worth checking your local credit unions if penfed isn’t for you.

  13. Anonymous

    I use a regular Discover Card. They have these “more” bonus categories that rotate every 3 months. Starting July 1st to September 30th, they offer 5% on gas, and hotels (and maybe another category). It is free to sign up and is just a click on their website. I also have a Chase Freedom card that offers 3% on the top 3 categories and 1% on everything else. There is a limit though for both of these. The discover card has a limit of 5% for the first $400, and Chase is $600 for the 3% bonus. No limit for the 1%.

    Although I will never spend $400 per month on gas, others might, so it is good to know there is a limit.

  14. Anonymous

    Agree w/PiggyBankBlues on the BP Visa Card. 10% back on BP Gas (which is the least expensive where I live anyway) for the first 60 days, 5% back afterwards. No fee, and 2% (4% first 60 days) on dining/travel, 1% (2% first 60 days) on everything else. Driving 500+ miles/week makes this one my default choice…

  15. Anonymous

    One more thing True Earnings Card from Costco and AmEx gives you is 2% on travel expenses such as flights, car rentals, and hotels. You do have to spend the rebate at costco though.

    If we ignore this though (to make the comparison easier) The blue cash card will give you a bigger rebate if you charge over $13k a year, the true earnings will give you a bigger rebate if you charge under $13k a year. If you spend exactly $13k, they both give you 3% back on gas and 1% back on everything else.

  16. Nickel

    FlatGreg: Correct. But if I were to buy gas elsewhere, I would use a card that gives me 5% cash back. But I’ll add that clarification.

  17. Nickel

    livingalmostlarge: I’m confused… As far as I know, the Citi Simplicity card is no longer available (though they’ve presumably allowed existing accounts to remain open). But more to the point, wasn’t the 5% cash back on gas and groceries just a 12 month promo, at which time it fell back to 1%?

  18. Anonymous

    nice round-up, thanks. i recently researched gas cards and in the end opted for a BP credit card through chase. there’s three stations within a mile of me, and the 10% back for this summer couldn’t be beat. the 5% thereafter isn’t bad, either…

  19. Anonymous

    Yeah, the Blue Cash is pretty sweet. I also use the Chase Freedom card. It pays 3% on the top 3 of 15 categories, one of which is gas.

    The nice thing about the Chase Freedom card is that the gas rebate is a flat 3% instead of starting out at 1.0% for a while before becoming 5% at the magic $6,500 mark. Because of the tiering, the Freedom card can sometimes end up paying a person more in gas rebates than the Blue Cash — depending on what the person’s spending levels are.

  20. Anonymous

    Think the AMEX kickback comes on an anniversary, not on a standard preset day of the year. I get mine in April. However, mine’s from Costco.

  21. Nickel

    Patrick: It’s based on your card anniversary date, though in my case (and presumably Vicky’s) that nearly the same as the calendar year.

    Matt: A small number of card apps won’t have much of an effect on your credit score, and it’s typically a short-lived effect. See here for more details.

  22. Anonymous

    I just opened an AmEx Simply Cash Business Card a month ago because of the 5% gas rebate. ARG!!!

    I plan on buying a house within the next 2 years so I don’t want to mess with my credit score too much. If I didn’t have a house purchase on the way I would probably get the Blue Cash from AMEX.

  23. Anonymous

    I have always received my bonus from Amex in January, but I cannot remember if that’s my card anniversary or not. I’ve been using it as my primary means of paying for everything since around Christmas and the $244 accumulated so far is quite a satisfying figure.

Leave a Reply